List of Top 100 Insurance Companies in Florida Ranked by Policies In Force.
Wells Law Group, P.A., Florida Hurricane Attorneys logoInsurance Companies List
Slogan Representing families and businesses in disputes with insurance companies throughout Florida. logo
navigation
navigation
 

Insurance Companies in florida

List of Top 100 Insurance Companies in Florida Ranked by Policies In Force (PIF)

Rank Insurance Company PIF Phone Number
1 Citizens Property Insurance Corporation 17.0% (850) 513-3700
2 State Farm Florida Insurance Company 14.6% (863) 318-3000
3 Universal Property & Casualty Insurance Co 7.5% (954) 958-1200
4 St. Johns Insurance Company, Inc. 3.2% (407) 226-8460
5 United Services Automobile Association 2.7% (210) 498-2211
6 Castle Key Insurance Company 2.6% (727) 573-6800
7 Asi Assurance Corp. 2.2% (727) 573-6800
8 Nationwide Insurance Company Of Florida 2.1% (614) 249-7111
9 Royal Palm Insurance Company 2.0% (800) 509-1592
10 Universal Insurance Company Of North America 1.8% (941) 378-8851
11 Florida Peninsula Insurance Company 1.7% (561) 994-8366
12 Magnolia Insurance Company 1.6% (305) 858-9500
13 Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company 1.6% (617) 357-9500
14 American Strategic Insurance Corp 1.6% (727) 821-8765
15 American Integrity Insurance Company Of FL 1.5% (813) 880-7000
16 Florida Family Insurance Company 1.4% (239) 495-4700
17 Tower Hill Prime Insurance Company 1.3% (800) 509-1592
18 Homewise Insurance Company, Inc 1.3% (813) 202-8600
19 Usaa Casualty Insurance Company 1.3% (210) 498-2211
20 Southern Fidelity Insurance Company 1.2% (850) 521-3080
21 United Property & Casualty Insurance Company 1.2% (727) 895-7737
22 Castle Key Indemnity Company 1.1% (727) 573-6800
23 Homeowners Choice Property & Casualty Ins 1.1% (727) 213-3675
24 Hartford Insurance Company Of The Midwest 1.0% (860) 547-5000
25 Sunshine State Insurance Company 1.0% (904) 285-1879
26 American Bankers Insurance Company Of FL 0.9% (305) 253-2244
27 Security First Insurance Company 0.9% (386) 673-5308
28 Florida Farm Bureau Casualty Insurance CO 0.9% (352) 378-8100
29 Foremost Insurance Company 0.8% (616) 942-3000
30 Southern Oak Insurance Company 0.8% (904) 353-4000
31 Homewise Preferred Insurance Company 0.8% (813) 202-8600
32 Florida Farm Bureau General Insurance CO 0.8% (352) 378-8100
33 Tower Hill Select Insurance Company 0.7% (800) 509-1592
34 Tower Hill Preferred Insurance Company 0.7% (800) 509-1592
35 First Protective Insurance Company 0.7% (407) 444-5224
36 American Traditions Insurance Company 0.7% (727) 561-0013
37 Cypress Property & Casualty Insurance CO 0.7% (904) 992-4492
38 Capitol Preferred Insurance Company, Inc 0.7% (850) 521-0742
39 Foremost Property And Casualty Insurance CO 0.6% (616) 942-3000
40 Northern Capital Insurance Company 0.6% (800) 306-9180
41 First Community Insurance Company 0.6% (727) 823-4000
42 Omega Insurance Company 0.6% (800) 509-1592
43 Safeway Property Insurance Company 0.5% (352) 333-0160
44 First Liberty Insurance Corporation 0.5% (617) 357-9500
45 Federated National Insurance Company 0.5% (954) 581-9993
46 First Floridian Auto And Home Insurance CO 0.5% (813) 890-4200
47 Olympus Insurance Company 0.5% (321) 558-3950
48 Edison Insurance Company 0.5% (727) 579-9850
49 First Home Insurance Company 0.5% (904) 292-5200
50 Federal Insurance Company 0.4% (908) 903-2000
51 Amica Mutual Insurance Company 0.4% (800) 652-6422
52 Cotton States Mutual Insurance Company 0.4% (309) 821-3000
53 People'S Trust Insurance Company 0.3% (561) 988-9170
54 Gulfstream Property And Casualty Insurance 0.3% (941) 388-0905
55 United Casualty Insurance Company Of America 0.3% (314) 819-4300
56 Auto-Owners Insurance Company 0.3% (517) 323-1200
57 Modern Usa Insurance Company 0.3% (727) 489-9028
58 Teachers Insurance Company 0.3% (217) 789-2500
59 Fidelity Fire & Casualty Company 0.3% (407) 444-5224
60 Metropolitan Casualty Insurance Company 0.2% (401) 827-2400
61 Cincinnati Insurance Company 0.2% (513) 870-2000
62 American Home Assurance Company 0.2% (212) 770-7000
63 Hillcrest Insurance Company 0.2% (800) 509-1592
64 Argus Fire & Casualty Insurance Company 0.2% (305) 521-0400
65 American Modern Insurance Company Of FL 0.2% (800) 543-2644
66 American Southern Home Insurance Company 0.2% (800) 543-2644
67 Aca Home Insurance Corp 0.2% (727) 821-8765
68 Safe Harbor Insurance Company 0.2% (850) 386-1115
69 Fireman'S Fund Insurance Company 0.2% (415) 899-2000
70 American Mercury Insurance Company 0.2% (405) 621-6590
71 Companion Property And Casualty Insurance 0.2% (803) 735-0672
72 Northern Capital Select Insurance Company 0.2% (800) 306-9545
73 Asi Preferred Insurance Corp 0.2% (727) 821-8765
74 Liberty American Select Insurance Company 0.1% (727) 546-8911
75 Hartford Fire Insurance Company 0.1% (860) 547-5000
76 American Reliable Insurance Company 0.1% (480) 483-8666
77 Fidelity National Property And Casualty Ins 0.1% (800) 849-6140
78 New Hampshire Insurance Company 0.1% (212) 770-7000
79 Encompass Floridian Insurance Company 0.1% (847) 402-5000
80 American Keystone Insurance Company 0.1% (904) 273-9777
81 Coop De Seguros Multiples De Puerto Rico 0.1% (787) 622-8585
82 Liberty American Insurance Company 0.1% (727) 546-8911
83 Armed Forces Insurance Exchange 0.1% (913) 727-5500
84 Southern-Owners Insurance Company 0.1% (517) 323-1200
85 Hartford Insurance Company Of The Southeast 0.1% (860) 547-5000
86 Encompass Floridian Indemnity Company 0.1% (847) 402-5000
87 American Federation Insurance Company 0.1% (616) 942-3000
88 Usaa General Indemnity Company 0.1% (210) 498-2211
89 Ids Property Casualty Insurance Company 0.1% (920) 330-5100
90 Foremost Signature Insurance Company 0.1% (616) 942-3000
91 Nova Casualty Company 0.0% (716) 856-3722
92 Ark Royal Insurance Company 0.0% (888) 746-4275
93 American Automobile Insurance Company 0.0% (415) 899-2000
94 Electric Insurance Company 0.0% (978) 921-2080
95 Travelers Indemnity Company Of America 0.0% (860) 277-0111
96 Privilege Underwriters Reciprocal Exchange 0.0% (914) 328-7388
97 Auto Club Insurance Company Of Florida 0.0% (888) 929-4222
98 Old Dominion Insurance Company 0.0% (904) 642-3000
99 Homesite Insurance Company Of Florida 0.0% (617) 832-1300
100 Owners Insurance Company 0.0% (517) 323-1200

The following is a list obtained in 2009 from the State of Florida's website. The list may not be current and is subject to change.