| Rank |
Insurance Company |
PIF |
Phone Number |
| 1 |
Citizens Property Insurance Corporation |
17.0% |
(850) 513-3700 |
| 2 |
State Farm Florida Insurance Company |
14.6% |
(863) 318-3000 |
| 3 |
Universal Property & Casualty Insurance Co |
7.5% |
(954) 958-1200 |
| 4 |
St. Johns Insurance Company, Inc. |
3.2% |
(407) 226-8460 |
| 5 |
United Services Automobile Association |
2.7% |
(210) 498-2211 |
| 6 |
Castle Key Insurance Company |
2.6% |
(727) 573-6800 |
| 7 |
Asi Assurance Corp. |
2.2% |
(727) 573-6800 |
| 8 |
Nationwide Insurance Company Of Florida |
2.1% |
(614) 249-7111 |
| 9 |
Royal Palm Insurance Company |
2.0% |
(800) 509-1592 |
| 10 |
Universal Insurance Company Of North America |
1.8% |
(941) 378-8851 |
| 11 |
Florida Peninsula Insurance Company |
1.7% |
(561) 994-8366 |
| 12 |
Magnolia Insurance Company |
1.6% |
(305) 858-9500 |
| 13 |
Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company |
1.6% |
(617) 357-9500 |
| 14 |
American Strategic Insurance Corp |
1.6% |
(727) 821-8765 |
| 15 |
American Integrity Insurance Company Of FL |
1.5% |
(813) 880-7000 |
| 16 |
Florida Family Insurance Company |
1.4% |
(239) 495-4700 |
| 17 |
Tower Hill Prime Insurance Company |
1.3% |
(800) 509-1592 |
| 18 |
Homewise Insurance Company, Inc |
1.3% |
(813) 202-8600 |
| 19 |
Usaa Casualty Insurance Company |
1.3% |
(210) 498-2211 |
| 20 |
Southern Fidelity Insurance Company |
1.2% |
(850) 521-3080 |
| 21 |
United Property & Casualty Insurance Company |
1.2% |
(727) 895-7737 |
| 22 |
Castle Key Indemnity Company |
1.1% |
(727) 573-6800 |
| 23 |
Homeowners Choice Property & Casualty Ins |
1.1% |
(727) 213-3675 |
| 24 |
Hartford Insurance Company Of The Midwest |
1.0% |
(860) 547-5000 |
| 25 |
Sunshine State Insurance Company |
1.0% |
(904) 285-1879 |
| 26 |
American Bankers Insurance Company Of FL |
0.9% |
(305) 253-2244 |
| 27 |
Security First Insurance Company |
0.9% |
(386) 673-5308 |
| 28 |
Florida Farm Bureau Casualty Insurance CO |
0.9% |
(352) 378-8100 |
| 29 |
Foremost Insurance Company |
0.8% |
(616) 942-3000 |
| 30 |
Southern Oak Insurance Company |
0.8% |
(904) 353-4000 |
| 31 |
Homewise Preferred Insurance Company |
0.8% |
(813) 202-8600 |
| 32 |
Florida Farm Bureau General Insurance CO |
0.8% |
(352) 378-8100 |
| 33 |
Tower Hill Select Insurance Company |
0.7% |
(800) 509-1592 |
| 34 |
Tower Hill Preferred Insurance Company |
0.7% |
(800) 509-1592 |
| 35 |
First Protective Insurance Company |
0.7% |
(407) 444-5224 |
| 36 |
American Traditions Insurance Company |
0.7% |
(727) 561-0013 |
| 37 |
Cypress Property & Casualty Insurance CO |
0.7% |
(904) 992-4492 |
| 38 |
Capitol Preferred Insurance Company, Inc |
0.7% |
(850) 521-0742 |
| 39 |
Foremost Property And Casualty Insurance CO |
0.6% |
(616) 942-3000 |
| 40 |
Northern Capital Insurance Company |
0.6% |
(800) 306-9180 |
| 41 |
First Community Insurance Company |
0.6% |
(727) 823-4000 |
| 42 |
Omega Insurance Company |
0.6% |
(800) 509-1592 |
| 43 |
Safeway Property Insurance Company |
0.5% |
(352) 333-0160 |
| 44 |
First Liberty Insurance Corporation |
0.5% |
(617) 357-9500 |
| 45 |
Federated National Insurance Company |
0.5% |
(954) 581-9993 |
| 46 |
First Floridian Auto And Home Insurance CO |
0.5% |
(813) 890-4200 |
| 47 |
Olympus Insurance Company |
0.5% |
(321) 558-3950 |
| 48 |
Edison Insurance Company |
0.5% |
(727) 579-9850 |
| 49 |
First Home Insurance Company |
0.5% |
(904) 292-5200 |
| 50 |
Federal Insurance Company |
0.4% |
(908) 903-2000 |
| 51 |
Amica Mutual Insurance Company |
0.4% |
(800) 652-6422 |
| 52 |
Cotton States Mutual Insurance Company |
0.4% |
(309) 821-3000 |
| 53 |
People'S Trust Insurance Company |
0.3% |
(561) 988-9170 |
| 54 |
Gulfstream Property And Casualty Insurance |
0.3% |
(941) 388-0905 |
| 55 |
United Casualty Insurance Company Of America |
0.3% |
(314) 819-4300 |
| 56 |
Auto-Owners Insurance Company |
0.3% |
(517) 323-1200 |
| 57 |
Modern Usa Insurance Company |
0.3% |
(727) 489-9028 |
| 58 |
Teachers Insurance Company |
0.3% |
(217) 789-2500 |
| 59 |
Fidelity Fire & Casualty Company |
0.3% |
(407) 444-5224 |
| 60 |
Metropolitan Casualty Insurance Company |
0.2% |
(401) 827-2400 |
| 61 |
Cincinnati Insurance Company |
0.2% |
(513) 870-2000 |
| 62 |
American Home Assurance Company |
0.2% |
(212) 770-7000 |
| 63 |
Hillcrest Insurance Company |
0.2% |
(800) 509-1592 |
| 64 |
Argus Fire & Casualty Insurance Company |
0.2% |
(305) 521-0400 |
| 65 |
American Modern Insurance Company Of FL |
0.2% |
(800) 543-2644 |
| 66 |
American Southern Home Insurance Company |
0.2% |
(800) 543-2644 |
| 67 |
Aca Home Insurance Corp |
0.2% |
(727) 821-8765 |
| 68 |
Safe Harbor Insurance Company |
0.2% |
(850) 386-1115 |
| 69 |
Fireman'S Fund Insurance Company |
0.2% |
(415) 899-2000 |
| 70 |
American Mercury Insurance Company |
0.2% |
(405) 621-6590 |
| 71 |
Companion Property And Casualty Insurance |
0.2% |
(803) 735-0672 |
| 72 |
Northern Capital Select Insurance Company |
0.2% |
(800) 306-9545 |
| 73 |
Asi Preferred Insurance Corp |
0.2% |
(727) 821-8765 |
| 74 |
Liberty American Select Insurance Company |
0.1% |
(727) 546-8911 |
| 75 |
Hartford Fire Insurance Company |
0.1% |
(860) 547-5000 |
| 76 |
American Reliable Insurance Company |
0.1% |
(480) 483-8666 |
| 77 |
Fidelity National Property And Casualty Ins |
0.1% |
(800) 849-6140 |
| 78 |
New Hampshire Insurance Company |
0.1% |
(212) 770-7000 |
| 79 |
Encompass Floridian Insurance Company |
0.1% |
(847) 402-5000 |
| 80 |
American Keystone Insurance Company |
0.1% |
(904) 273-9777 |
| 81 |
Coop De Seguros Multiples De Puerto Rico |
0.1% |
(787) 622-8585 |
| 82 |
Liberty American Insurance Company |
0.1% |
(727) 546-8911 |
| 83 |
Armed Forces Insurance Exchange |
0.1% |
(913) 727-5500 |
| 84 |
Southern-Owners Insurance Company |
0.1% |
(517) 323-1200 |
| 85 |
Hartford Insurance Company Of The Southeast |
0.1% |
(860) 547-5000 |
| 86 |
Encompass Floridian Indemnity Company |
0.1% |
(847) 402-5000 |
| 87 |
American Federation Insurance Company |
0.1% |
(616) 942-3000 |
| 88 |
Usaa General Indemnity Company |
0.1% |
(210) 498-2211 |
| 89 |
Ids Property Casualty Insurance Company |
0.1% |
(920) 330-5100 |
| 90 |
Foremost Signature Insurance Company |
0.1% |
(616) 942-3000 |
| 91 |
Nova Casualty Company |
0.0% |
(716) 856-3722 |
| 92 |
Ark Royal Insurance Company |
0.0% |
(888) 746-4275 |
| 93 |
American Automobile Insurance Company |
0.0% |
(415) 899-2000 |
| 94 |
Electric Insurance Company |
0.0% |
(978) 921-2080 |
| 95 |
Travelers Indemnity Company Of America |
0.0% |
(860) 277-0111 |
| 96 |
Privilege Underwriters Reciprocal Exchange |
0.0% |
(914) 328-7388 |
| 97 |
Auto Club Insurance Company Of Florida |
0.0% |
(888) 929-4222 |
| 98 |
Old Dominion Insurance Company |
0.0% |
(904) 642-3000 |
| 99 |
Homesite Insurance Company Of Florida |
0.0% |
(617) 832-1300 |
| 100 |
Owners Insurance Company |
0.0% |
(517) 323-1200 |
The following is a list obtained in 2009 from the State of Florida's website. The list may not be current and is subject to change.
